What's All This Carbide Talk..
The US Industry Code (C-2, C-4, etc.) ratings system needs to be
understood before making purchasing decisions based on this alone.
There seems to be industry wide inconsistencies regarding this rating
system. While we do not claim to be carbide specialist, we do have a good
example of how carbide ratings can become confusing.
We have two charts listed from two major US carbide suppliers. While
Infinity Tools advertises a C-4 Micrograin Carbide cutting surface,
different manufactures can call the same carbide by a different name.
For example, in chart #1 the gray bar indicates Infinity bits would
have a C-4 US Industry Code, while Chart #2 indicates Infinity bits would
have a C-2 US Industry Code.
So how can you know what we are actually buying? It's a good question
with a complicated answer.
With all the proprietary secrets and marketing names put on carbide
these days the only way to accurately compare carbide is to compare their
actual specifications. (If you can get them)
Carbide is primarily made of Tungsten and Cobalt. Simply, the more
Tungsten you have the harder the carbide. Cobalt is the binder in this
powdery mixture. (Remember though, the harder the carbide the more brittle
it becomes)
Compare the Tungsten (WC) and Cobalt (Co) percentages. Next compare the
Transverse Rupture Strength. (TRS) Finally, compare the hardness.
(HRA)
If all these are the same you can feel confident you are comparing
similar carbide products, and therefore similar cutting surfaces.
Unfortunately, it doesn't stop there. Obviously, the method in which
carbide is ground has a great impact on the quality of the cutting
surface.
More to the point you can have a high quality carbide that has been
inadequately ground resulting in a premium carbide bit that cuts no better
than an inexpensive one.
In the end, it is our experience that you look for many of the
characteristics of a premium bit, (type of carbide, steel, braze, etc.)
and try them.
The more experienced you become with different router bits the easier
it will be to spot an inferior product regardless of their marketing
claims. |